The Management Problem Remote Work Exposed

enascend.com-Articol-The Management Problem Remote Work Exposed

Every few months, the debate starts again.

Three days in the office. Two days at home. Mandatory collaboration days. Flexible Fridays. Camera-on meetings. Camera-off meetings.

One almost expects the next breakthrough to depend on the phase of the moon.

Organisations should keep experimenting because every business is different, every team has its own dynamics and every stage of growth creates different challenges. What is surprising is our belief that someone has finally discovered the formula everyone else has been missing, even though organisations are not trying to solve the same problem.

A software company struggling to innovate is not facing the same challenge as a manufacturing business trying to improve operational discipline. A fast-growing sales organisation has different needs from a professional services firm built around independent specialists. Prescribing exactly the same way of working to all of them is rather like telling every patient they need the same treatment simply because they arrived complaining of a headache.

Perhaps that explains why the debate never ends. Organisations change direction, declare success, then adjust the policy a year later. More often than not, they simply discover that someone else’s solution did not solve their own problem.

Maybe we have been asking the wrong question.

The real question was never where people work. It was how organisations build trust when they can no longer rely on visibility.

For decades, managers saw people arriving in the morning, moving between meetings, eating lunch at their desks or staying late to finish a project. Nobody formally decided that these were signs of commitment, but over time they became reassuring. Seeing people work created confidence that work was getting done.

When that disappeared, organisations looked for a replacement.

Green dots became signs of engagement, instant replies became signs of commitment and packed calendars became signs of importance. Without really intending to, many organisations replaced physical visibility with digital visibility.

Employees adapted quickly. Somewhere, someone is moving the mouse every few minutes to stop the screen from going idle. Somewhere else, another person is replying almost immediately, not because the answer cannot wait, but because waiting five minutes somehow feels uncomfortable. Green has quietly become one of the most reassuring colours in modern management.

We saw this during a workshop with the leadership team of a company that had embraced hybrid working. The discussion turned to engagement, productivity and whether managers still had enough visibility over their teams. One executive proudly observed that digital collaboration had never been stronger.

A senior developer smiled before saying, “I spend half my day managing my Slack status so nobody thinks I’m making coffee.”

Everyone laughed, then the room became unexpectedly quiet.

The joke worked because everyone recognised the truth behind it. Highly skilled professionals had started managing appearances instead of creating value because they had learned what the organisation seemed to reward.

The uncomfortable part is that leadership is caught in exactly the same system.

Managers are rarely trying to control people. Most are trying to answer a reasonable question: How do I know my team is doing well?

The difficulty is that performance requires judgement, context and an understanding of the work itself. Visibility is easier to measure, and dashboards, response times, attendance figures and online indicators create the impression that performance can be observed directly.

When organisations confuse visibility with performance, they gradually begin rewarding the things that are easiest to see rather than the things that matter most.

Meetings multiply because full calendars look reassuring. Fast responses become more valuable than thoughtful ones. Constant availability quietly becomes part of what good performance is supposed to look like. Everyone becomes busier proving that work is happening while paying less attention to whether the work itself is improving.

The return-to-office movement has produced its own quiet paradox.

Many organisations describe office days as opportunities for collaboration, yet employees often spend an hour commuting only to sit in an open-plan office wearing noise-cancelling headphones while joining video meetings with colleagues working somewhere else. Physical presence has returned, but the way people work often looks much the same.

Neither remote work nor the office is automatically the answer. Both can succeed and both can fail because the policy itself is rarely the deciding factor. What matters is whether the way people work reflects the work they do and the organisation they are trying to build.

Perhaps that is the most useful lesson the remote work debate has given us.

It did not create a management problem. It exposed one that had been there all along.

Once managers could no longer rely on seeing people work, organisations were forced to confront a much harder question than where employees should spend their week. They had to decide what they actually meant by trust, performance and accountability.

The next time somebody confidently announces they have finally solved remote work, it may be worth asking a different question.

Not, “How many days should people come into the office?”

But, “What organisational problem are we actually trying to solve?”

Because the answer will probably not fit into a three-day schedule.

Share: